Luke is a loser college boy who blames everything wrong with his life on his bad looks. Thinking life would be easier if he were beautiful, he finds a spell to steal his beautiful philosophy professor's life so he can have it easy as a trophy wife.

Ben is jealous of his best friend Allen’s success in life. Allen has an amazing, beautiful wife named Scarlet, a great job, and a perfect house, while Ben has none of these things. But when Ben makes a wish using a magical hand-me-down to have all that Allen has, things go much further than he intends. Soon all Ben, Allen, and Scarlet all find their roles rearranged . . . permanently.